COLO Compass | Following the Money: What COLOs Shared About Online Budget Models

By Julie Uranis, Ph.D.
This is a bonus COLO Compass blog post following the November 17 C-COLO Coffee Chat.
On November 17, 2026, the Council for Chief Online Learning Officers hosted a coffee chat focused on financial models. The following blog post shares some of the discussion and important observations concerning the state of online enterprise financial models.
Accountability Has Outpaced Authority
Leaders from public systems, flagship research universities, and comprehensive state institutions described the same bind: they are held to enrollment and net revenue targets while tuition setting, distance education fees, and revenue allocation formulas stay in central hands.
Many of these structures date from a time when online learning was an auxiliary experiment or an offshoot of continuing education. Central budget offices still set fees and allocations with little attention to what digital delivery costs, including marketing, instructional design, specialized technology, and student support across channels.
Every Campus Runs a Different Funding System
One facilitator opened by acknowledging that no two participants work under the same arrangement. Some operate within responsibility center management, some negotiate revenue shares college by college, and some sit in centralized or distributed units where every answer starts with “it depends.” Five models came up in the discussion.
| Model | How it is funded | Where it strains |
| Centralized flat budget | Fixed annual allocation from the provost or general fund | No incentive tied to growth; new investments depend on the provost relationship |
| Market-rate incubator | Market tuition set outside state caps, kept by the unit for an initial period (three years in one example) | Programs must prove viability before they fold into the general budget |
| Distance education fee | Per-credit fee pays for instructional design, media, and technology | No control over pricing or course supply; surpluses draw campus scrutiny |
| Central service unit with noncredit revenue | General fund subsidy for academic support; unit keeps noncredit revenue | No share of credit tuition growth; the unit is seen as a cost center |
| Capped self-support | Unit keeps online tuition, but revenue above the approved budget goes to central | Unit carries operating risk while its upside is capped |
The Models Strain in Predictable Places
Flat budgets run on relationships. At one regional public university, online learning receives a fixed annual allocation for operations and core technology. Online enrollments are not broken out from total enrollment in institutional reporting, so growth is hard to document. Any expenditure beyond the baseline, such as new AI instructional tools, depends on the provost’s willingness to cover it, and an upcoming change in senior leadership leaves that arrangement exposed.
Market pricing comes with an expiration date. In one public system, online programs for adult learners use a market-rate exception to set tuition outside state caps. Some campuses run these as incubators: the unit keeps market tuition for about three years to pay for development and marketing, and then the program moves into the general budget. Rising employee benefit costs and legislative pressure on distance fees squeeze margins along the way.
Fee surpluses invite scrutiny. An urban research university funds its central online unit through a distance education fee that pays for instructional designers, media production, and technology. Academic departments decide which courses go online, and faculty teach them in load, so fee revenue swings without the unit controlling supply. During the pandemic, fee revenue surged while the campus ran general fund deficits. System rules capped carryover at 50% of the prior year’s revenue and barred fee dollars from paying permanent faculty salaries, yet colleagues facing cuts still saw the reserve as money that should help them.
Old handshake deals have to be unwound. At another public university, summer and winter course revenue had funded the online unit. Earlier leaders used that money to support faculty lines in academic colleges through informal agreements, some covering people who no longer taught online. A budget model overhaul replaced the summer/winter tuition funding with a direct central allocation and returned summer/winter revenue to the colleges, which let the online unit shed those commitments. The institution is working through a new online learning budget model that relies on course-level distance fees, since online participation reaches well beyond fully online students: more than a third of all students take at least one online course.
Reinvested fees can seed new programs. During university-wide cuts, one institution reinstated a distance education fee tied to credit hours and returned half of the revenue to academic colleges through a structured proposal process. Departments used those funds to launch 10 new online degree programs.
A capped upside meets regional competition. After a merger brought an adult-serving college into a larger university, the combined online enterprise runs self-supporting undergraduate programs alongside graduate programs. It must cover its operating costs, but any revenue above the approved annual projection goes to the central budget. A large national online provider’s tuition rates essentially serve as a cap at least one institution in the area abides by.
Three Pressures Cut Across Every Model
Informal agreements obscure the budget. Unwritten deals made by past administrators to fund faculty lines, grant special revenue splits, or buy local equipment lock money into commitments no one planned. When new leaders try to standardize financial policy, those deals turn into disputes between units and between people.
Budget calendars and census dates do not line up. Budget offices often want firm projections in February or March, but census-verified headcount and tuition revenue may not be final until late spring or summer. Online leaders end up building budgets on projected enrollment while distributing incentives on actual revenue.
Distance fees have become a political target. Legislators and governing boards in more than one state have asked why online courses, which the public often assumes cost less to deliver, carry an extra fee. If fees disappear without replacement funding, instructional design and technology support lose their base.
Documentation and Data Strengthen the Case
Participants pointed to steps within a COLO’s reach, even without control over pricing.
- Put every agreement in writing. Review existing revenue shares, stipends, and salary subsidies, and replace informal deals with memoranda of understanding that carry end dates, performance measures, and quality expectations.
- Code online students consistently. Work with the registrar and IT to distinguish fully online program students, hybrid learners, and residential students taking an online course in the student information system. Without that baseline, arguments for formula-based funding have little to stand on. A recent UPCEA member forum thread examined this practice.
- Attach quality to revenue sharing. Link enhanced tuition share or course development funds to departments’ use of central instructional design support and course quality standards.
- Bring finance into the conversation. Benchmark models with peers through UPCEA, build working relationships with central finance officers, and seek out peers with common budget model concerns (e.g. distance fee management or RCM).
While none of these moves hands tuition- and fee-setting authority to the online unit, they do equip COLOs with the records, data, and allies they need when budget decisions are made.
AI Disclosure
This post was developed with the support of an AI research and writing assistant. AI assistance was used to identify and review relevant sources, verify facts and citations, explore related evidence and examples, develop and revise draft language, and identify claims that warranted additional scrutiny or qualification. When possible, research was verified against primary or authoritative sources.
The topic, editorial direction, argument, source priorities, and decisions about what evidence to include and how to interpret it were guided by the human author. AI-generated research and draft language were reviewed and revised iteratively, including efforts to distinguish documented findings from inference, identify limitations in the available evidence, and avoid claims that extended beyond what the sources could support.
AI-assisted content is treated as draft material rather than final work. Before publication, the author reviewed the analysis, verified material facts and source characterizations, and determined that the conclusions reflect appropriate professional and institutional judgment. The author is responsible for the accuracy and final content of the piece.
Learn more about UPCEA's expert consultants.
Do you need help with your PCO unit or campus? We can help. Contact UPCEA Research and Consulting for a brief consult. Email [email protected] or call us at 202-659-3130.
Trusted by the nation's top colleges and universities, UPCEA Research and Consulting provides the best value in the industry today. UPCEA's industry experts have years of experience in Online and Professional Continuing education - put them to work for you!
UPCEA Research and Consulting offers a variety of custom research and consulting options through an outcomes-focused pricing model. Find the option(s) that best suit your institution.
Learn more about UPCEA Research & Consulting
The UPCEA Difference
Unmatched Experience: For more than 100 years, UPCEA consultants have exclusively served the needs of online and professional continuing education programs. UPCEA consultants leverage their extensive industry expertise to expedite solutions, anticipate upcoming shifts, and offer distinct best practices, effectively aiding clients in achieving their goals.
Cost Effectiveness: As a nonprofit, member-serving organization, we provide unmatched value, allowing you to maximize limited research and consulting budgets.
Action in Motion: Our cadre of experienced, skilled authorities and expert practitioners propels you forward, translating research and consulting into impactful implementation, a distinctive hallmark of UPCEA. Our team of current and former institutional leaders will support you, turning research and consulting into action.
Mission Alignment: Like you, our mission is to enhance and expand educational opportunities and outcomes for adult and other non-traditional learners. We share your values and work in partnership with you to advance access and excellence in education.
