The Smart City and Crime: Can the Criminology Degree Rehabilitated?
Crime in the United States is projected to decline. Hollywood gives us many dramatic scenarios of what the future could be, although over the next few decades, it is unlikely to be that depicted in the Sylvester Stallone movie Judge Dredd, where crimes are judged and punished on the spot. However, with the adoption of greater technologies and the use of predictive analytics, the scenario illustrated in Tom Cruise’s Minority Report is more likely, although crime will be predicted in advance by supercomputers rather than by mythical beings called “pre-cogs.” This is more realistic given the power of computing at hand coupled with vast amounts of data being collected.
While the public perception is that crime rates have not improved or have gotten worse[i], they have actually been on the decline in the United States for quite some time. The reasons include a variety of factors and possibilities. Some attribute the rise or decline of crime to crackdowns or influences of illegal drugs, the economy, alcohol usage or even gun control. Another possibility would be the decriminalization of certain crimes, such as the use of marijuana in some states.
However, one argument as a deterrent to crime is advances in technology such as the use of cell phones to report or record a crime. New technologies including the use of surveillance cameras, analytics and predictive methods, DNA testing and smart building technologies are having an impact. As a result, it is expected that new technologies will improve enforcement and prevention which most likely will result in greater efficiencies and labor changes which are forecasted to increase over the next decade. Table 1 shows a predicted 6% increase in detectives and criminal investigators, police and sheriff’s patrol officers and other professions. However, forecasts show that given the demographics of the country coupled with decreased immigration, the United States is expected to see historically low population growth over the next decade[ii].
Table 1 – Occupational Statistics (Emsi 2019)
Using Emsi data, the table below shows an analysis of job postings as they relate to the “law enforcement” category. The table shows the posting intensity to be high for those in the analyst community. This coupled with a high median posting duration suggests higher demand or an inability to fill open positions.
Table 2 – Job Analytics for Law Enforcement Workers (SOC 33-3000)
With law enforcement jobs and the landscape of crime changing, it is also likely that the criminal justice degree is in need of an overhaul. Many degree programs have classic courses in juvenile delinquency, drug abuse, the corrections system and the court and justice systems. Some even have courses specific to gender or race. However, few curricula that the UPCEA Center for Research and Strategy reviewed had topics related to new technologies or current issues.
Figure 1 – Snapshot of One Institution’s Curriculum
With the advancement of new technologies, is the attractiveness of a degree in criminal justice or criminal studies less? Do institutions need to consider a revision to curricula to address the use and deploying of new technologies, cybercrime, crimes of today, identity theft, conflict between law enforcement and society, new approaches to race relations, new approaches to community policing, the impact of DNA or forensics, or the use of analytics to prevent crime?
With the approach of a new economy fueled by automation and improved communication, it is likely that crime in monitored places will decrease. Quantum-computing accessing enormous data sets coupled with a video-driven society will likely prevent, predict or identify crime. A traditional response to a crime has been a show of human force. A future response could take the form of drones and other mechanized devices. New training will also be needed, as will new curriculum. Law enforcement, like the military, often uses simulations and other preparatory exercises. The use of virtual or augmented reality technologies could also improve law enforcement approaches in a new economy. New weapons, lethal and non-lethal, are certain to enter the law enforcement community. Improvements to facial recognition and other identifying technologies will also improve to the point of adoption.
With all of these developments impacting law enforcement, policies and laws will change. How law enforcement personnel and technologies are managed, used, and deployed will also be subject to change. The courts and legal system will change, thus opening up new avenues of training and education.
Higher education will need to re-evaluate its existing curriculum for relevancy. Institutions will also have an opportunity to provide new training to those with existing criminal justice credentials. They will also have opportunities to deploy new certificates or badges in evolving content areas. To sit back and do nothing and continue using dated curriculum while promising graduates jobs and good salaries in a new economy would be a crime in itself.
[i] Pew Research Center and Gallup research
[ii] Brookings Institute
Lead consultant Jim Fong, the founding director of UPCEA’s Center for Research and Strategy, has extensive background in marketing at Penn State, as well as experience in private industry. Jim brings a rich understanding of the dynamics driving today’s higher education leaders, providing research-driven strategy and positioning. Jim often presents at UPCEA’s regional and national conferences, sharing vital information with attendees.
Whether you need benchmarking studies, or market research for a new program, UPCEA Consulting is the right choice.
We know you. We know the challenges you face and we have the solutions you need. We speak your language and have been serving leaders like you for more than 100 years. UPCEA consultants are current or former continuing and online higher education professionals who are experts in the industry—put our expertise to work for you.
Data that tells your story.
Whether you need to assess the viability of a new program, find out how you stack up with the competition or would like a program portfolio review, we can assist with research and data that will help move your unit forward. Your decisions impact the quality of your operation, as well as the bottom line. We’ll provide data that does more than sit on a page—it’s data that tells the story.
The UPCEA Center for Research and Strategy offers a variety of custom research options through a variable pricing model.
Other UPCEA Updates + Blogs
20 Individuals and 14 Programs Honored Across 5 Regions WASHINGTON, September 22, 2022 – UPCEA, the leader in professional, continuing, and online education, has announced the recipients of the 2022 Regional Awards. Each of UPCEA’s five Regions recognizes both individual and institutional achievement of the UPCEA members within the Region. Award recipients will be honored…Read More
UPCEA is pleased to announce the 2022 cohort of Bethaida “Bea” González Diversity in Leadership Scholars. Representative and diverse leadership is a cornerstone of UPCEA’s Commitment to Diversity and Inclusive Excellence. The goal of the Diversity Scholars program is to equip diverse professionals at any stage of their career with the skills and knowledge needed…Read More
Biden Administration Announces Long-Awaited Student Debt Forgiveness, Signals End of Student Loan Payment Pause | Policy Matters (August 2022)
Major Updates Biden Administration Announces Long-Awaited Student Debt Forgiveness, Signals End of Student Loan Payment Pause After years of anticipation, the Biden Administration rolled out its student debt forgiveness and repayment package. While the $10,000 in forgiveness for any individual making less than $125k per year (or $250k jointly) which was included in the final…Read More
In order to improving the security and functionality of our member login, we would like to inform you about an email verification step you will see soon. Starting on Friday September 9th, when you log in to your user profile on the UPCEA member portal, you will receive an email from: Sender: MemberSuite Support <[email protected]>…Read More
Conference Committee Nixes Short-Term Job Training Pell Grants from Final Compromise Computer Chip Bill | Policy Matters (July 2022)
Major Updates Conference Committee Nixes Short-Term Job Training Pell Grants from Final Compromise Computer Chip Bill After months of internal negotiations between a conference committee working out differences between the House and Senate passed legislation focusing on competitiveness with China, a much narrower compromise bill has come forth. Smaller than the House of Representatives’ original…Read More
One size doesn’t fit all — Differences among Boomer learners, retirees, and the mature adult learner BOSTON, MA and WASHINGTON, DC (July 29, 2022) – Driven by Baby Boomer retirements and the Great Resignation, a new wave of mature learners is looking at options in continuing education – but not necessarily to learn new job skills,…Read More