The Pulse of Higher Ed

Perspectives on Online and Professional Education
from UPCEA’s Research and Consulting Experts

Leading by Gut or by Data: The Data-Driven State of Higher Ed Decision Making

In recent years, the idea of data-driven decision making has been propelling much of the higher education narrative. As many industries work to incorporate data and analytics into their organizational processes, education providers are also tasked with adopting a more thoroughly informed management approach. A 2013 report titled Building Organizational Capacity for Analytics highlighted that “enhanced analytics is critical to both optimizing student success and achieving institutional effectiveness.” Undoubtedly, a data-driven mindset should penetrate all levels of higher education decision making, from program development to student retention and graduation.

In an increasingly competitive higher education environment, the benefits of advanced data collection and analytics permeate all aspects of both student success and institutional success. Yet while higher education has been flooded with calls to adopt a data-driven mindset, the adoption of this ethos is proving difficult for many institutions to implement in practice. In an attempt to understand how higher education institutions have actually incorporated the use of data and analytics into their decision making, Helix Education and UPCEA (the University Professional and Continuing Education Association) have partnered to conduct a study of the use of metrics and the creation of a data-driven environment.

The primary goal of this research was to outline the current landscape of decision making among higher education providers and assess the role of data in management and leadership. While many institutions have introduced some data analysis activities to inform some decisions, this research reveals that for a majority of education providers, data science and analytics are being underutilized when making decisions about program development, marketing, enrollment, and retention services—a reality leading to a waste of both financial resources and staff time. For example, almost half of those surveyed indicated that they have no formalized system in place to determine which new programs are developed, and the majority of institutions don’t know their estimated conversion rate from inquiry to enrollment. While higher education is slowly adopting technologies and processes that drive data integration and analysis, the majority of institutions are hamstrung by a lack of data integration or capacity for data analytics.

A secondary goal of this research was to assess how colleges and universities are mitigating barriers to the data-driven mindset. Many embrace the idea that experience and intuition are not enough to make efficient and effective decisions at all institutional levels. For those institutions that acknowledge gaps in their capacity to be data-driven, this research shows that many are looking to outsourced partners for help.

 

Snapshot of Key Findings

  • Eighty-three percent of respondents indicated no knowledge of the cost-per-inquiry of their most effective marketing channel for undergraduate inquiry, and more than half made the same indication for graduate inquiry.
  • Sixty-eight percent of respondents don’t know their estimated overall conversion rate from inquiry to start.
  • Less than half of respondents have a formalized system in place to determine which new programs are developed.
  • Only thirty-eight percent of respondents reported close integration between marketing, enrollment management, and advising teams.

 

UPCEA Members: Click here to login to CORe to download the complete PDF of the report.

Not an UPCEA Member?: Call 202-659-3130 for more information.

Authored by

Learn more about UPCEA's expert consultants. 

Do you need help with your PCO unit or campus? We can help. Contact UPCEA Research and Consulting for a brief consult. Email [email protected] or call us at 202-659-3130.

Trusted by the nation's top colleges and universities, UPCEA Research and Consulting provides the best value in the industry today. UPCEA's industry experts have years of experience in Online and Professional Continuing education - put them to work for you!

UPCEA Research and Consulting offers a variety of custom research and consulting options through an outcomes-focused pricing model. Find the option(s) that best suit your institution.

Learn more about UPCEA Research & Consulting


The UPCEA Difference

Unmatched Experience: For more than 100 years, UPCEA consultants have exclusively served the needs of online and professional continuing education programs. UPCEA consultants leverage their extensive industry expertise to expedite solutions, anticipate upcoming shifts, and offer distinct best practices, effectively aiding clients in achieving their goals.

Cost Effectiveness: As a nonprofit, member-serving organization, we provide unmatched value, allowing you to maximize limited research and consulting budgets.

Action in Motion: Our cadre of experienced, skilled authorities and expert practitioners propels you forward, translating research and consulting into impactful implementation, a distinctive hallmark of UPCEA. Our team of current and former institutional leaders will support you, turning research and consulting into action.

Mission Alignment: Like you, our mission is to enhance and expand educational opportunities and outcomes for adult and other non-traditional learners. We share your values and work in partnership with you to advance access and excellence in education.

Other UPCEA Updates + Blogs

COLO Compass | States Need to Know What Online Learning Costs Before Deciding What It’s Worth

COLO Compass: Evidence and practical direction for chief online learning officers. Georgia put a question on the table that every state should be asking: What does online education actually cost? Earlier this year, Georgia’s state Senate proposed paying public colleges roughly 91 cents for every dollar of online instruction relative to campus instruction, meaning online…

How Institutions Build Strong Noncredit and Professional Education Portfolios

Noncredit and professional education has moved from the margins of the institution to the center of enrollment and workforce strategy. As traditional pipelines tighten and adult learners look for faster, skills-focused options, colleges and universities are rethinking what they offer beyond the degree. Yet a scattered collection of one-off courses often do not deliver lasting…

When Leadership Leaves a Mark: Moving Forward After a Difficult Institutional Experience

Leadership is not defined only by the circumstances we encounter, but also by how we learn from them and determine what comes next.  Higher education leaders often accept positions because they believe in an institution’s mission and see opportunities to make a meaningful difference. They bring experience, professional judgment, and a commitment to supporting students,…

UPCEA Announces Indiana State University as 2026 Jim Fong Grant Recipient

WASHINGTON, D.C., November 10, 2026 — UPCEA is pleased to announce that the 2026 Jim Fong Grant for Advancing Online and Professional Education has been awarded to Indiana State University. Indiana State’s project will use a landscape survey and regional data analysis to find where the university is best positioned to build stackable, non-credit-to-credit credential…

COLO Compass | Who Leads Next? Building the Pipeline of Online Leaders

COLO Compass: Evidence and practical direction for chief online learning officers. Throughout National Distance Learning Week, I’ve written about how much online learning leaders are now expected to handle: AI governance, the financial case for online education, relationships with policymakers, financial aid fraud, and operations that extend well beyond their own units. The question for…

COLO Compass | The COLO’s Job Got Bigger. Has the Authority Kept Up?

COLO Compass: Evidence and practical direction for chief online learning officers. When UPCEA published its 2016 Hallmarks, online education was still moving from innovation to mainstream adoption, and a central challenge was legitimizing it. The 2026 Hallmarks of Excellence in Digital Learning Enterprises begin from a different premise. As Vickie Cook, a contributing editor of…

The Nation's Top Universities Choose UPCEA Research and Consulting

Informed decisions. Ideas that work. The data you need. Trusted by the top universities in the nation.