The Pulse of Higher Ed

Perspectives on Online and Professional Education
from UPCEA’s Research and Consulting Experts

Pruning Programs to Help a Portfolio Bloom

A man (Bruce Etter) is dressed in a blue suit smiling for a headshot.

By Bruce Etter

On a recent soggy summer day, I sauntered into my yard with a pair of loppers in one hand and my trusty instructor, my phone, in the other. For the first time, I was going to prune our rose bushes. Like many millennials, I consulted the internet prior to embarking on this task to better understand not only how to prune a rose bush (which seemed intuitive enough), but also why I should do so. What I learned is that while pruning encourages increased blooms, more importantly, it protects the remainder of the bush from potential diseases. As I was removing the dead and diseased canes, I found myself thinking about the parallels between a college or university’s portfolio of programs and the bush I was delicately tending to.

Over the last few years UPCEA’s Research and Consulting team has reviewed thousands of programs through its portfolio decision-making model (PDMM). All too often, we would see the equivalent of diseased or dying programs within an institution’s portfolio. While programs may have once bloomed with enrollments, they may now be in decline, steadily losing the vitality they once knew. Rather than institutions recognizing and compassionately removing these programs from the portfolio, they are left to languish on in a destitute perpetuity, sapping resources that could better serve the portfolio elsewhere. Although it may be clear that action is needed to stop the prolonged programmatic decay, there is often a lack of guidance on how and when to make those decisions.  

UPCEA’s June 2023 snap poll found that nearly two-thirds (64%) of respondents disagreed (41%) or strongly disagreed (23%) with the notion that their institution has a clearly defined set of metrics and parameters for determining if a program should be sunset. Despite the lack of clear guidelines, the poll found 80% of institutions have sunset a program within the last three years, averaging 5.3 programs per institution during that time span. These were most often non-credit (37%), followed by graduate degrees (20%) and graduate certificates (22%).[1] As higher education’s competitive market continues to tighten, it will be critical for institutions to have established parameters for sunsetting programs, and to effectively communicate those metrics to faculty and staff.

Given the understandable sensitivities around sunsetting programs, it is imperative that the process is driven by data. Most programs begin with promise and hope for the institution. People develop relationships with and through the program. Some programs can have successful multi-decade runs before their time runs out. Because of this, individuals in and around the program can feel as though a decision to sunset a program is a reflection on how an institution may value them or their work. With these realities in mind, academic leaders must have empathetic ears while also operating on clearly defined metrics. Measurable metrics that can influence the decision to sunset a program include but are not limited to program inquiries, applications, enrollments, student retention, gross revenue, marketing costs, faculty costs, and net revenue, among others.

Furthermore, assessing whether the program is meeting a market need is essential. In addition to internal metrics, institutions should look beyond their own borders to better understand program viability. Assuming new programming decisions are driven by relevant data, rather than gut feelings or pressure from donors, it is important to ask if the market factors that led to the creation of the program still hold true. Resources such as the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) can inform whether or not other institutions are experiencing sustained drops in enrollments. Organizations like Lightcast can detail labor market forecasts and in-demand skills for occupations associated with the program. UPCEA can provide feasibility studies or custom consulting to aid in these decisions. Potential challenges can stem from a lack of perceived value, marketing issues, program nomenclature, program isolation, curriculum relevancy, and tuition, among others. While some of these issues can be addressed, others cannot. Regardless of the root cause or causes, institutions need to be transparent around the sunsetting process. 

Some institutions, like Sonoma State University, have policies that emphasize that program discontinuation should not be a response to short-term financial crises or personnel shortages, but instead should result from factors such as underfunding, insufficient faculty, or inadequate support.[2] To avoid situations where there is dispute over discontinuing an academic program, the University of Wisconsin has a planning process for discontinuing or suspending degree/major programs and certificate programs. The process involves the review and approval of proposals by the academic department that owns the program, the school/college, the University Academic Planning Council for undergraduate programs, and the Graduate Faculty Executive Committee Council for graduate programs. The approved proposals are then reported to relevant offices within UW-Madison by the Provost’s Office.[3]

Closing an academic program is a complex decision that requires careful consideration and communication. Administrators must assess whether program closure is truly necessary, while also recognizing potential costs such as lost confidence in the institution from students, staff, or faculty, resistance from alumni and other program supporters, and potentially negative press. Additionally, the institution will need to create a thoughtful teach out plan for individuals that are actively enrolled in the program and strategize where to best use the expertise of faculty that were involved with the program. Furthermore, closing programs solely as a response to financial constraints may not result in significant short-term savings unless other cost-saving measures are implemented.[4]

With these potential challenges in mind, it is crucial to have a clear, compelling, and unwavering case for why a program is being closed, ensuring consistent communication of the decision, process, and rationale to stakeholders. Recognizing that the closure process can be political, administrators need to understand stakeholder dynamics and the need for inclusive listening. Implementing decisions requires attention to detail and a focus on people, as closing a program can be emotionally challenging for those involved.[5] Sunsetting academic programs requires a comprehensive assessment of various factors and considerations for stakeholders to understand the reason behind the decision and for the discontinuation process to run smoothly. In order to have clear communication and know when it is appropriate to sunset an academic program, it is essential that institutions have clear guidelines in place.While sunsetting a program is always going to be a difficult decision, it is sometimes necessary to protect the greater health of the portfolio and the institution. Much like my rosebush, understanding why and when the cut needs to be made is paramount to carrying out the task effectively. Resources that had been spent on the declining program can instead be used to nurture other offerings and help the totality of the portfolio thrive. 

 

Bruce Etter, Senior Director of Research & Consulting, is responsible for developing and managing research initiatives for UPCEA Research and Consulting and its clients. He graduated from Penn State University with a Bachelor’s of Science in Sociology and a minor in Sustainability Leadership.

 

[1] UPCEA June 2023 Snap Poll

[2] https://academicaffairs.sonoma.edu/academic-programs/curriculum-guide/discontinuing-academic-program

[3] https://kb.wisc.edu/apir/page.php?id=116213

[4] https://www.chronicle.com/article/what-to-consider-when-closing-an-academic-program/

[5] https://www.chronicle.com/article/what-to-consider-when-closing-an-academic-program/

Authored by

Learn more about UPCEA's expert consultants. 

Do you need help with your PCO unit or campus? We can help. Contact UPCEA Research and Consulting for a brief consult. Email [email protected] or call us at 202-659-3130.

Trusted by the nation's top colleges and universities, UPCEA Research and Consulting provides the best value in the industry today. UPCEA's industry experts have years of experience in Online and Professional Continuing education - put them to work for you!

UPCEA Research and Consulting offers a variety of custom research and consulting options through an outcomes-focused pricing model. Find the option(s) that best suit your institution.

Learn more about UPCEA Research & Consulting


The UPCEA Difference

Unmatched Experience: For more than 100 years, UPCEA consultants have exclusively served the needs of online and professional continuing education programs. UPCEA consultants leverage their extensive industry expertise to expedite solutions, anticipate upcoming shifts, and offer distinct best practices, effectively aiding clients in achieving their goals.

Cost Effectiveness: As a nonprofit, member-serving organization, we provide unmatched value, allowing you to maximize limited research and consulting budgets.

Action in Motion: Our cadre of experienced, skilled authorities and expert practitioners propels you forward, translating research and consulting into impactful implementation, a distinctive hallmark of UPCEA. Our team of current and former institutional leaders will support you, turning research and consulting into action.

Mission Alignment: Like you, our mission is to enhance and expand educational opportunities and outcomes for adult and other non-traditional learners. We share your values and work in partnership with you to advance access and excellence in education.

Other UPCEA Updates + Blogs

Systems of Trust: Making Credential Value Visible, Verifiable, and Meaningful

Insights and practical considerations from the UPCEA 2026 Chief Credential Innovation Officer Convening October 13, 2026 | Washington, DC What makes a credential valuable? The answer depends on more than the knowledge or skills it represents. A credential must communicate something meaningful to learners, provide credible evidence to employers, and retain its value as individuals…

COLO Compass | Following the Money: What COLOs Shared About Online Budget Models

This is a bonus COLO Compass blog post following the November 17 C-COLO Coffee Chat. On November 17, 2026, the Council for Chief Online Learning Officers hosted a coffee chat focused on financial models. The following blog post shares some of the discussion and important observations concerning the state of online enterprise financial models. Accountability…

COLO Compass | Beyond the Online Program: Leading the Systems That Support Learner Success

COLO Compass: Evidence and practical direction for chief online learning officers. For many institutions, online learning success has traditionally been measured through enrollment growth, new program development, and revenue generation. These remain important indicators of institutional performance, but they tell only part of the story. An institution may successfully recruit learners into well-designed online programs…

COLO Compass | States Need to Know What Online Learning Costs Before Deciding What It’s Worth

COLO Compass: Evidence and practical direction for chief online learning officers. Georgia put a question on the table that every state should be asking: What does online education actually cost? Earlier this year, Georgia’s state Senate proposed paying public colleges roughly 91 cents for every dollar of online instruction relative to campus instruction, meaning online…

How Institutions Build Strong Noncredit and Professional Education Portfolios

Noncredit and professional education has moved from the margins of the institution to the center of enrollment and workforce strategy. As traditional pipelines tighten and adult learners look for faster, skills-focused options, colleges and universities are rethinking what they offer beyond the degree. Yet a scattered collection of one-off courses often do not deliver lasting…

When Leadership Leaves a Mark: Moving Forward After a Difficult Institutional Experience

Leadership is not defined only by the circumstances we encounter, but also by how we learn from them and determine what comes next.  Higher education leaders often accept positions because they believe in an institution’s mission and see opportunities to make a meaningful difference. They bring experience, professional judgment, and a commitment to supporting students,…

The Nation's Top Universities Choose UPCEA Research and Consulting

Informed decisions. Ideas that work. The data you need. Trusted by the top universities in the nation.