UPCEA Updates

The latest association offerings and updates. UPCEA is your association!

How to Measure the Impact of Your Leadership Development Programs

No matter the size of your school or educational institution, it’s no secret that strong leadership is crucial to long-term success. Implementing leadership development programs is among the most effective ways to train aspiring educational leaders and ensure their goals and mission are aligned with that of the institution.

At the same time, it’s not always simple to gauge the success of leadership development programs—which is why it’s important to have a system in place for measuring specific outcomes. With a better understanding of how to develop key performance indicators (KPIs) and collect and analyze data, you can optimize the success of these programs and achieve better learning outcomes.

Why Measure Leadership Development?

Why is it so important to measure leadership development program outcomes, anyway? There are several reasons to consider, beginning with the fact that having solid data to support the results of your programs can help demonstrate your return on investment (ROI) and justify further program funding.

Analyzing your leadership development programs can:

  • Quantify the program’s impact on key organizational outcomes like student success, employee engagement, and retention.
  • Provide data-driven evidence to secure continued funding and support for leadership development initiatives.

Likewise, assessing your leadership development programs can improve overall program effectiveness by:

  • Identifying areas where the program is achieving desired outcomes and where improvement is necessary.
  • Making data-driven decisions to optimize program content, delivery methods, and resources.

Finally, when you measure leadership development programs within your institution, you can enhance accountability and transparency by:

  • Demonstrating program accountability to stakeholders, including school leaders and faculty involved in program design and implementation, as well as students benefiting from the program.
  • Building trust and confidence in the value of leadership development programs.

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for Leadership Development

When assessing a leadership development program in an education setting, several key performance indicators (KPIs) should be closely examined. In doing so, it is possible to get a more comprehensive view of the program’s effectiveness as a whole—as well as its impact on individuals.

Behavioral Change

Measuring behavioral change within a leadership development program involves focusing on specific, observable behaviors and how they align with program objectives. When measuring this KPI, it is also essential to look at changes in leadership behaviors using such tools as surveys, 360-degree feedback, and performance evaluations.

Additionally, assessing behavioral change as a KPI should include tracking improvements in leadership skills, such as communication, decision-making, and conflict resolution.

Impact on Individuals

Looking at a leadership development program’s impact on individuals within the institution is also crucial; it should involve assessing their development through self-reflection and performance coaching along with tracking career advancement progress. Whenever possible, assessing the impact of a given program should mean measuring identifiable changes in leadership self-efficacy, confidence, and motivation from one leadership development participant to the next.

Impact on Teams and Groups

For many leadership development programs, one of the primary goals is to get leadership teams collaborating and communicating more effectively. In measuring the success of these programs, then, it’s critical to look not just at individual leaders but also groups and teams.

Specifically, this means taking the time to evaluate changes in team collaboration, communication, and problem-solving. Meanwhile, assessing this KPI may require looking more closely at team performance metrics (such as productivity, innovation, and engagement) while also tracking improvements in team dynamics and morale.

Impact on the Institution

The most effective leadership development initiatives are those that have sweeping impacts on the entire institution. So, what can you measure to determine the impact of your program on the school or institution at large?

Start by measuring changes in key organizational metrics, such as:

  • Student retention
  • Graduation rates
  • Employee satisfaction

Then, assess improvements in institutional culture, climate, and decision-making. From there, you can also track the financial return on investment of your leadership development programs—which can be helpful if you’re seeking additional funding for future initiatives.

The Kirkpatrick Model for Measuring Training Effectiveness

In measuring the effectiveness of your institution’s leadership development training, the tried-and-true Kirkpatrick Model can be especially useful. The Kirkpatrick Model refers to a framework first developed by Donald Kirkpatrick in the 1950s, consisting of four levels of evaluation that can effectively assess the results of training from numerous perspectives. The idea is that each level builds upon the previous one, ensuring that all program participants are getting the most out of it.

There are four models in the Kirkpatrick Model: 

  1. Level One: Reaction – At this beginning stage, you’re analyzing specifically the degree to which participants find the training engaging, relevant, and enjoyable to attend. This should include a close look at how involved and engaged participants are during training as well as how relevant the information they’re learning is to their jobs and roles as higher education leaders.
  2. Level Two: Learning – The next level is where you evaluate the degree to which participants in a leadership development program are acquiring the information and skills they’re intended to learn. To measure this, you’ll need to have concrete learning outcomes for your program before it’s even implemented. You can use tools like post-program checks and testing to determine just how much participants are getting out of the program.
  3. Level Three: Behavior – Next, look at behavior change—the degree to which participants can actually use what they learned in the program when working in leadership roles themselves. If the skills learned in the program aren’t being applied in the real world, what’s the point?
  4. Level Four: Results – The final level of the Kirkpatrick Model focuses on measuring results. In an educational leadership program, this would involve closely examining how well the targeted outcomes have been achieved as a direct result of the training. This should include measurement of the program’s overall ROI, which can be useful in securing future funding for similar training.

Effective Data Collection Methods

Collecting quality data is crucial to accurately measuring the success and outcomes of your leadership development program. The following are some tools and methods to collect valuable data:

  • Surveys A survey can help assess aspects like behavior change (how well leaders are employing what they’ve learned in their respective roles) and overall reaction to the training.
  • Interviews – For more in-depth responses and feedback, interviews can be especially useful when it comes to collecting qualitative data. Higher education leaders might consider sitting down with individual program participants to gauge their experience with the program. These interviews are ideally conducted in person but could be handled over the phone if scheduling conflicts arise.
  • Focus groups – These involve sitting down with numerous program participants at once and asking for focused feedback on different aspects of the program.
  • Performance data – Sometimes, simply looking at an educational leader’s performance data after completing leadership training and comparing it to data from before training can help gauge the effectiveness of the program.
  • Observation – Taking the time to sit down and observe higher education leaders in their everyday roles can also be a great way to see firsthand how they are applying principles and skills from leadership development programs in real-world situations.

Data Analysis and Reporting

Once data is collected, knowing how to analyze, interpret, and report it to stakeholders is key. You should leverage data analysis tools and techniques to identify trends and patterns within the data. From there, data can be translated into meaningful insights and actionable recommendations for future programs.

As part of interpreting program data, it’s also important to develop clear and concise reports that communicate the impact of leadership development programs to stakeholders.

Collaboration and Stakeholder Engagement

Key stakeholders should be involved in developing and implementing evaluation plans at every stage of the process. This means ensuring stakeholders understand the importance of measuring impact and the methodologies employed. Findings and recommendations should be disseminated to stakeholders in a timely, transparent manner so they can be as involved in the process as possible.

As you can see, putting in the work to measure the impact of your institution’s leadership development programs is vital—especially in the realm of education, where so many individuals rely on effective leadership at all levels.

If your institution is seeking help optimizing its leadership development programs and outcomes, our expert consultants at UPCEA are here to assist. Get in touch with our experienced and knowledgeable strategic advisors today to learn more about how our timely, actionable recommendations could take your next leadership development program to new levels of success. 






Suggested Citation

UPCEA. (2024, April 5). How to measure the impact of your leadership development Programs. UPCEA. https://upcea.edu/how-to-measure-the-impact-of-your-leadership-development-programs/

Other UPCEA Updates + Blogs

Who’s in the Driver’s Seat?

May 16, 2024

The saying “who’s in the driver’s seat” commonly refers to driving a car and the decision of whether one person…

Read More

Bringing an Insider-Outsider Perspective to UPCEA’s Members

April 23, 2024

Shortly after pivoting twelve years ago from a deanship to a faculty position, I realized the only job better than…

Read More

Get Involved with UPCEA

Professional development isn't just about attending sessions. Get involved with UPCEA to meet members from other institutions, share the great work your institution is doing, and hone your own skills. From submitting a session proposal for a conference or an article for a publication to serving as a volunteer on a conference planning committee, there are as many ways to engage with us!


Awards of Excellence

Since 1953, UPCEA has recognized its members' outstanding contributions to the Association and the field, as well as their achievements in innovative programming, marketing and promotion, community development and services, research and publications, and many other areas.