The Pulse of Higher Ed

Perspectives on Online and Professional Education
from UPCEA’s Research and Consulting Experts

From Degrees to Microcredentials: Higher Education Must Evolve to Embrace the Modern Economy

A person (Aaron Brower) smiles for a headshot.

By Aaron Brower

America’s appetite for four-year, 120-credit bachelor’s degrees has been declining for well over a decade. In addition, the National Student Clearinghouse recently released a report showing that undergraduate degree completion fell yet again. Bachelor’s degree graduates declined to their lowest level since 2015-16, with Associate’s degree graduates at their lowest level in ten years.    

The same National Student Clearinghouse report showed that earning a certificate while in college was at a new high, surpassing last year, which itself set a record.  

While this pattern of decline in degree completion and increased certificate attainment was accelerated by COVID-19, research since the late 1970s has documented that people have taken nontraditional paths through college, often without completion.   

And not because undergraduate degrees aren’t worth it.

 

People are Turning Away from a Degree Despite its Value 

Even though the cost of college has risen faster than other expenses, a recent Pew Research Center study – and virtually all studies – show college graduates have significantly higher annual and lifetime earnings than those without degrees, with some studies showing as much as an 84% difference.  

Health, wellness, and longevity, too, are better for college graduates. There’s no disputing the value of a college degree. As the Pew study shows, those with a college degree are doing better than ever.

So why are people continuing to turn away from the traditional undergraduate degree?

 

“DIY-ing” Higher Education to Keep Pace  

My view is that it’s not cost; it’s that these degrees are increasingly no longer the product that best serves the marketplace. Put simply, workforce demands are changing too fast for the 4-year, 120-credit degree to keep pace.  

Instead, people have adopted a different model of their own education and training pathways and do so throughout their lives.  

This pattern – mixing and matching lifelong education and training, (essentially, “unbundling” and “rebundling” learning experiences) – is pervasive. So much so, in fact, that some authors (myself included) argue that this pattern has revolutionized education and training.  

Individuals now move in and out of formal education, combining it with certifications, badges, and other workforce training. They are “DIY-ing” into the modal model of higher education.  

High-quality microcredentials are essential to this evolved model of higher education and training, whether they are credit-bearing credentials embedded in college curricula, or noncredit, stand-alone, and recognized by industry. 

Microcredentials are more popular than ever because businesses are increasingly turning to them to upskill and reskill their workforce. Business demand is so strong that they increasingly turn to for-profit providers when they can’t find microcredentials through colleges and universities.  

This lifelong DIY model of education and training is productive for people and our nation, driven by the needs of the modern workplace, and the population’s response to remain current, active, and engaged in their work throughout their lives.   

Colleges and universities that embrace this evolution are thriving. They’re figuring out how to provide an easily-stackable curriculum that learners unbundle and rebundle towards their education and workforce training. They’re figuring out how to make it super easy for their learners to continually step in and out of engagement with their institution. And, they’re figuring out new business models that support this type of lifelong, customized engagement. 

 

Challenges to the Microcredentials Evolution 

The rise in microcredentials, and their increasingly central importance in the education and training of Americans, is not without its problems.  

First and foremost, not all microcredentials are of equally high quality. The need for quality standards for microcredentials is significant, and several think tanks and professional organizations have begun to set out quality standards for microcredentials. (Two examples come from the Higher Learning Commission and the Council of Chief State School Officers.)  

Second, the rise of microcredentials is also being driven by the rise in skill-based hiring. When done correctly, this is a practice that not only improves the quality of employee recruitment but can also reduce hiring biases and inequities. However, transitioning to skills-based hiring is neither simple nor cheap.  

How best to support business transition to skills-based hiring is a known issue, with several handbooks and toolkits being developed for this purpose. (Jobs for the Future has one such toolkit.) 

Lastly, transitioning to and embracing a mix-and-match, lifelong engagement model requires real money, time, and ongoing support for colleges and universities. This applies to both front-of-house program development and back-of-house business and operational systems.  

Not all institutions can afford this time and money. In response, several professional organizations, including UPCEA, have developed support services and tools to help institutions make this transition. 

 

Can Microcredentials Save Higher Education? 

Jim Fong, UPCEA’s chief research officer, claimed in a recent Keystone podcast that the embrace of microcredentials can save higher education.  

Fong went on to clarify that this can only happen if institutions shift their exclusive focus away from the 15 million 18-year-olds entering U.S. higher education. Instead, they should also consider the roughly 40 million who have stepped out of college with no degree and the additional 40 million who are directly seeking workforce credentials. 

Click here to listen to Jim Fong on the Keystone Higher Ed Chats podcast. 

The need for high-quality, lifelong education and training is critical to the health and vitality of our nation and its people. Whether or not microcredentials themselves will save higher education, their continual rise, and the decline in formal degree completion, should not be seen as a nail in higher education’s coffin.  

Aside from self-preservation, higher education should embrace this evolved model of lifelong learning because it’s the right thing to do. Unbundling and rebundling, mixing and matching education and training is a productive model for people and the nation. By actively supporting learners in these activities, they make those efforts better for people and the entire nation – which is, ultimately, higher education’s historic role.

 

 

Aaron Brower, Ph.D., is a Strategic Advisor with UPCEA, a Fellow of the John N. Gardner Institute for Academic Transformation, and a Professor Emeritus at the University of Wisconsin – Madison. Aaron was formally a Provost, Interim Chancellor, and Senior Associate Vice President for Academic Affairs all within the University of Wisconsin System, where he was also the founding Executive Director of UW Extended Campus.

This post was originally published on the Keystone Education Group website.

Learn more about UPCEA's expert consultants

Do you need help with your PCO unit or campus? We can help. Contact UPCEA Research and Consulting for a brief consult. Email [email protected] or call us at 202-659-3130.

Trusted by the nation's top colleges and universities, UPCEA Research and Consulting provides the best value in the industry today. UPCEA's industry experts have years of experience in Online and Professional Continuing education - put them to work for you!

UPCEA Research and Consulting offers a variety of custom research and consulting options through an outcomes-focused pricing model. Find the option(s) that best suit your institution.

Learn more about UPCEA Research & Consulting


The UPCEA Difference

Unmatched Experience: For more than 100 years, UPCEA consultants have exclusively served the needs of online and professional continuing education programs. UPCEA consultants leverage their extensive industry expertise to expedite solutions, anticipate upcoming shifts, and offer distinct best practices, effectively aiding clients in achieving their goals.

Cost Effectiveness: As a nonprofit, member-serving organization, we provide unmatched value, allowing you to maximize limited research and consulting budgets.

Action in Motion: Our cadre of experienced, skilled authorities and expert practitioners propels you forward, translating research and consulting into impactful implementation, a distinctive hallmark of UPCEA. Our team of current and former institutional leaders will support you, turning research and consulting into action.

Mission Alignment: Like you, our mission is to enhance and expand educational opportunities and outcomes for adult and other non-traditional learners. We share your values and work in partnership with you to advance access and excellence in education.

Other UPCEA Updates + Blogs

Microcredentials, Modularity, and Mission: Insights from UPCEA’s Coffee Chat on Innovation in Healthcare Education

In partnership with the HELIX Summit on Continuing Medical Education  How are institutions navigating the dynamic intersection of workforce demands, digital learning, and credentialing innovation—especially in healthcare? That’s exactly what we explored in a recent Coffee Chat, where UPCEA leaders from across the higher education landscape gathered for an unrecorded but powerfully candid conversation on…

Read More

Leading with Values-Based Influence in Higher Education

Why Values-Based Influence Matters Now  Higher education is undergoing seismic shifts—demographic changes, budget constraints, AI disruption, and questions of relevance. In this environment, how we lead and why we lead matters as much as what we do as leaders. Leaders who operate from a strong internal compass—those grounded in values—offer clarity, stability, and hope.  Values-based…

Read More

Accreditation + Skill-Based Learning Addressed in New Executive Orders | Policy Matters (April 2025)

Major Updates Accreditation, Foreign Support, Skill-Based Learning Addressed in New Trump Executive Orders The Trump administration has continued issuing an unprecedented number of executive orders with recent directives directly impacting colleges and universities, addressing topics like accreditation reform, foreign influence, skills-based learning (including alternative credentials), and support for Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). Two…

Read More

Online education booms in an era of lifelong learning (WorkingNation)

‘Strictly online institutions tend to serve working-age or older adults requiring flexible schedules constructed around family obligations and work. “Folks arrive at higher ed for a multitude of reasons,” says Julie Uranis, senior vice president of online and strategic initiatives for UPCEA (the Online and Professional Education Association), a resource for online university programs. “Online learning gives them…

Read More

Your Lifelong Learning Journey’s “Breadcrumbs” – How to Tell Your Story

As avid backcountry hikers, years ago my family decided it would be prudent to buy a GPS, even though we had a rescue dog with an incredible sense of direction. While many out-and-back or even loop hikes didn’t require high-powered digital GPS coordinates to find our way back to our vehicle, we did appreciate launching…

Read More

Key Findings from 2024 UPCEA Marketing Survey

As more and more institutions face internal and external pressures to identify and cultivate new revenue streams, many are turning to online and professional continuing education to attract new learners and address fiscal shortfalls. While this continued increase in supply undoubtedly benefits the student, it makes an already saturated market even more competitive. UPCEA’s 2024…

Read More

The Nation's Top Universities Choose UPCEA Research and Consulting

Informed decisions. Ideas that work. The data you need. Trusted by the top universities in the nation.